NM Supreme Court denies petition to open Roundhouse during June special session
The New Mexico Supreme Court has denied a writ of mandamus regarding access to the Roundhouse during the upcoming special session set to begin June 18.
Chief Justice Judith Nakamura made the announcement late Tuesday after the Court listened to arguments earlier in the day. She said the Court was split on the issue and it would write an opinion.
Twenty-four New Mexico lawmakers submitted the petition on June 11, 2020, asking the court to block a decision by top-ranking legislators to close the Roundhouse to lobbyists and the public.
The New Mexico Foundation for Open Government (FOG) shares the petitioners’ concerns about any legislative action that would compromise the constitutional principle that “[a]ll sessions of each house shall be public.” This section of the Constitution – like another section providing that every piece of legislation must be “read publicly in full in each house, and thereupon … signed by the presiding officers of each house in open session” – makes clear that lawmaking can’t be allowed to take place out of the public eye.
At the same time, FOG finds it difficult to believe that these provisions disable the legislature from responding to emergencies that make in-person sessions impossible or unreasonably risky.
The language of the Open Meetings Act seems to be even clearer than these constitutional provisions – the statute says that “[a]ll meetings of any public body … shall be public meetings, and all persons so desiring shall be permitted to attend and listen to the deliberations and proceedings” – and yet our Supreme Court has held that “the words used mean only that the governmental entity must allow reasonable public access for those who wish to attend and listen to the proceedings” and should not be construed in a way that “unduly burden[s] the appropriate exercise of governmental decision-making and ability to act.”
That’s why FOG outlined a list of the remedies we proposed in a letter sent on June 11 to legislative leaders. The remedies include:
_▪_ all of the bills that will be voted upon must be publicly available 48 to 72 hours in advance of any votes;
_▪_ legislators must cease debate when their webcasting system inevitably crashes and not begin again until the webcast is back up and running;
_▪_ secret communications, such as Chat or any other running commentary function, are not available to the public at the time they are being made, therefore Legislators should not use them;
_▪_ accommodations be made for New Mexicans who require ADA accessible options and others who do not have internet access or personal computers and
_▪_ reporters and broadcasters should be allowed the greatest access possible to all proceedings inside the Roundhouse.
Advancements in technology have provided new ways for government to share information. By incorporating these technologies in the upcoming special session, FOG believes New Mexico lawmakers can create an environment of openness, transparency, honesty, accuracy and accountability.
Karen Moses retired from the position as Albuquerque Journal Editor and Senior Vice President in late May. She joined the Journal’s staff as a copy editor in 1981 after one year working at a weekly publication on Chicago’s North Shore and three years at the Gallup Independent. Moses is president of the New Mexico Foundation for Open Government, past president of the New Mexico Press Association, a graduate of Leadership New Mexico, a board member of the United Way of Central New Mexico and a member of the International Women’s Forum-New Mexico.
Jessica Onsurez is the news director of the Carlsbad Current-Argus, Alamogordo Daily News, Ruidoso News, Las Cruces Sun-News and the Farmington Daily-Times. She was a Peace Corps Community Economic Development Volunteer in Peru. Her career has also included work as an assistant in the office of U.S. Sen. Pete Domenici in Washington, DC.
Secretary Rashad Mahmood, Executive Director, New Mexico Local News Fund (443) 486-2406
Treasurer Sammy Lopez, Executive Director, New Mexico Press Association (505) 275-1241
Sammy Lopez is the executive director of the New Mexico Press Association. He has served as a publisher for newspapers in Las Cruces, Farmington, Carlsbad, Ruidoso, Deming, Fort Sumner and at the Valencia County News-Bulletin. Lopez also served in executive capacities with World West, where he was group manager for eight newspapers in three states, as well as Civitas Media, where, in addition to managing six daily and two weekly newspapers, he was instrumental in launching four real estate websites supported by four magazines. He is a past Dixon Award recipient.
Daniel Russell, Publisher, Hobbs News-Sun (575) 393-2123
Daniel Russell is the co-owner and publisher of Sunrise Publishing, which owns the Hobbs News-Sun. Prior to purchasing the News-Sun in January 2022, he was named by the previous owners as the publisher in 2013. Before being named publisher, he was the editor for 10 years, advertising manager for two years and a reporter for six years at the News-Sun. He began his career as a reporter at the Artesia Daily Press. He is or has been active in community theater, arts and various nonprofits in Lea County.
At-Large Member Paula Maes, President, New Mexico Broadcasters Association (505) 881-4411
Paula Maes is the president of the New Mexico Broadcasters Association. For many years she was the public affairs director at KOB-TV 4. She is a past member of the Albuquerque Public Schools Board of Education and is a current member of the APS Foundation Board of Directors. She is also active with the Children Cancer Fund of New Mexico. In 2023 she will be inducted into the NMBA Hall of Fame.
Immediate Past President, Kathi Bearden, Former Publisher, Hobbs News (575) 390-4776
Kathi Bearden is the retired publisher of the Hobbs Daily News-Sun where she received many awards from the New Mexico Press Association, the Associated Press and the New Mexico Press Women for outstanding journalism. She is the Past President of FOG, a past president of NMPA and is a recipient of the Dixon Award in Journalism. She is a business owner and has served on state and local boards.
Dede Feldman, Owner, The Feldman Co. (505) 242-1997
Dede Feldman has had a varied career as a journalist, high school and university teacher, and the owner of a small public relations business. She is the author of three books on New Mexico government. As the New Mexico State Senator for District 13, she served from 1997-2012. She is a past recipient of the Dixon Award in government.
Nate Gentry, Attorney, Gentry Law Firm, (505) 764-0111
Nate Gentry is a native New Mexican and a 2003 graduate of UNM School of Law. Prior to entering private practice, he worked for U.S. Senator Pete Domenici and served as counsel to the U.S. Senate. He was a member of the New Mexico House of Representatives for four terms where he was elected by his colleagues to serve as both minority and majority floor leader.
Chris Keller, Data Reporter, The Associated Press (505) 348-8323
Chris Keller is a data reporter at the Albuquerque Bureau of the Associated Press, He is a former managing editor of Albuquerque Business First as well as a deputy editor for graphics and data visualization for the LA Times. He has also worked in public radio and was a part-time lecturer at Loyola Marymount University in Los Angeles.
Henry Lopez, Digital Editor, Santa Fe New Mexican (505) 986-3054
Rashad Mahmood, Executive Director, New Mexico Local News Fund (443) 486-2406
Rashad Mahmood is the Executive Director of the New Mexico Local News Fund. Before coming to New Mexico a decade ago, he worked in international development in Washington DC, Egypt and Iraq. He has worked in print, online and radio journalism. In New Mexico, he worked for the youth media organization Generation Justice and KUNM 89.9 FM Radio.
Lucas Peerman, Digital Editor, Albuquerque Journal (505) 823-3840
Lucas Peerman is the digital editor at the Albuquerque Journal. Prior to that position, he was the editor of the Las Cruces Sun-News. He was also a copy editor at the Santa Fe New Mexican and worked at the Boston Globe. He is a graduate of New Mexico State University with a degree in journalism. While there, he was the managing editor of the student paper, the Roundup, and was awarded awarded Best Non-Daily College Newspaper by the Society of Professional Journalists. He was a longtime board member for Big Brothers Big Sisters in southern New Mexico and was a member of the 2015 Leadership Las Cruces class.
Charles Peifer is principal at Peifer, Hanson, Mullins & Baker, P.A. Before joining the Office of the New Mexico Attorney General, where he supervised the work of 30 lawyers in four civil law divisions, he practiced law at Rodey, Dickason, Sloan, Akin & Robb, P.A. He is listed in the Best Lawyers in America, has served as an adjunct faculty member for the University of New Mexico Law School Evidence and Trial Practice Program.
Charles "Kip" Purcell is a director of the Rodey Law Firm, a past president of FOG, and a 2014 Dixon Award winner. He was law clerk to the Honorable Ruth Bader Ginsburg, U. S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, 1984-1985. He was also a member of the Harvard Law Review from 1982 to 1984 and was Executive Editor of that journal from 1983 to 1984. He graduated from the University of Virginia and Harvard Law School.
Mary Lynn Roper, former President and General Manager, KOAT (505) 379-7979
Mary Lynn Roper retired as president & general manager of KOAT-TV, the Hearst Television ABC affiliate serving the New Mexico, television market. She spent 48 years in broadcasting, first in radio at station KRTN in her hometown of Raton, New Mexico. In 2005 Roper was inducted into the New Mexico Broadcasters Hall of Fame; in 2008 she was named New Mexico Broadcaster of the Year; and in 2013 she received an American Advertising Federation of New Mexico Silver Medal.
Kristelle Siarza, CEO, Siarza Social Digital (505) 234-6900
Kristelle Siarza has been the owner of Siarza Social Digital since 2014. Prior to opening her own firm she worked at The Garrity Group Public Relations, Heritage Hotels and Resorts, and the Greater Albuquerque Chamber of Commerce. She is a past board president of the Domestic Violence Resource Center Inc. and Filipino American Community Council and the United Way of Central New Mexico.
Rebecca Valdez, Assistant News Director KOB TV-4 (505) 243-4411
Rebecca Valdez is the Assistant News Director and Executive Producer at KOB-TV 4 where she supervises a team of producers, reports and news anchors to execute weekday news coverage for the 5 p.m., 6 p.m. and 6:30 p.m. shows. She was also Producer/Interim Morning Executive Producer at CBS 4 Denver, Denver CO and an evening Executive Producer at KRQE News 13. Her coverage of the 2010 Balloon Fiesta as nominated for an Emmy Award.
Gregory Williams has 20 years of experience practicing law. He is a past president of the board of directors of FOG and a past Dixon award recipient. He is a former President of the Board of Directors of the Alumni Association of the UNM School of Law. He has degrees from Princeton University and the UNM School of Law where he served as the editor-in-chief for the Law Review.
Melanie J. Majors
Executive Director
2333 Wisconsin St NE
Albuquerque, NM 87110 [email protected]
